1. Home
  2. News & Issues
  3. Civil Liberties

Top 10 Civil Liberties News Stories of the Week - August 11, 2006 Edition

By Tom Head, About.com

1 of 10

London Terrorism Scare Reignites Ethnic Profiling Debate

British Airways Jetliner

A British Airways jetliner.

Photo: Copyright (c) 2004 Jenny W. Used by permission.
On the heels of last week's arrest of 24 suspected terrorists plotting to destroy as many as ten U.S. bound airliners, the conservative punditocracy has responded by suggesting that the United States target passengers by ethnic origin. The Wall Street Journal brought this up, almost as an afterthought, in an editorial that also called for harsher treatment of prisoners and increased warrantless surveillance:
Another issue that should be front and center again is ethnic profiling ... Here in the U.S., the arrests should be a reminder of the dangers posed by a politically correct system of searching 80-year-old airplane passengers with the same vigor as screeners search young men of Muslim origin. There is no civil right to board an airplane without extra hassle ...
Actually, there is such a civil right--and it's explicated by the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Whatever our feelings about ethnic profiling, concerns regarding discrimination on basis of race or ethnic group should never be casually swept aside under the heading of "political correctness."

And besides, there is no such thing as "Muslim origin." One of the 24 men arrested in London was born Don Stewart-Whyte. Richard Reid, the would-be shoe bomber, was half-Jamaican. Ethnic profiling has made terrorist bombers a more ethnically diverse group, but it is no substitute for more substantive security measures. To accept it as such isn't just unconstitutional; it's dangerous.

1 of 10

Explore Civil Liberties

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. News & Issues
  3. Civil Liberties
  4. History & Profiles
  5. Top 10 Civil Liberties News Stories of the Week - August 11, 2006 Edition (London Terrorism Scare Reignites Ethnic Profiling Debate)

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.